The Political Junkies
archived: 4 - 10 Feb, 2007 Back Next
UPDATED: FEBRUARY 7, 2007
CHANGES
The national headline grabbing story today is Gallup’s new poll showing Bush’s approval rating taking a rather dramatic drop. But, an equally important poll was conducted by Rasmussen testing attitudes toward Bush’s continuing intervention in the Iraqi civil war.
When should troops be brought home from Iraq?
|
|
Feb. 2007 |
Nov. 2006 |
|
Bring home immediately |
37% |
28% |
|
Bring home within a year |
18% |
26% |
|
Stay until mission finished |
33% |
32% |
Source: Rasmussen Reports: Methodology: Telephone interviews with 800 likely American voters, conducted on Jan. 31 and Feb. 1, 2007. Margin of error is 3 per cent.
If this poll is not ultimately proved to be an “outlier,” Rasmussen is documenting a dramatic shift in American attitudes. A significant plurality of Americans want America out of the civil war and 55% of Americans want troops home now or within a year. Despite Bush’s direct plea for patience and his subsequent case for continuing participation in the civil war made in his State of the Union address, Americans who are willing to “stay the course” has not risen significantly.
Americans are hardening their position against Bush and the Republicans. If these trends continue and the Republican Party continues to defy its expression in Congress; an electoral price will be rightfully extracted.
As for Bush, Gallup’s latest poll offers a real surprise; one Democrats need to understand. Read, “TAKING ON WATER” in THEM DEMS.
BUSH’S VISION & REALITY
Bush expressed his vision of government on June 9, 2000:
Americans see a government slow to respond, slow to reform, and ignoring all the changes going on around it. I have set forth policies that capture my vision of government reform, guided by three principles: government should be citizen-centered, results oriented, and, wherever possible, market-based. In size and scale, modern government will never resemble what the framers envisioned. In spirit, however, it should always be citizen-centered, always listening and answering directly to the people.
The reality of what Bush gave Americans looking for the government Bush promised (emphasis added):
The Department of Defense . . . once again finds itself under intense scrutiny, only this time because it couldn't account for more than a trillion dollars in financial transactions, not to mention dozens of tanks, missiles and planes.
The Pentagon's unenviable reputation for waste will top the congressional agenda this week, when the House and Senate are expected to begin floor debate on a Bush administration proposal to make sweeping changes in how the Pentagon spends money, manages contracts and treats civilian employees.
The Bush proposal, called the Defense Transformation for the 21st Century Act, arrives at a time when the nonpartisan General Accounting Office has raised the volume of its perennial complaints about the financial woes at Defense, which recently failed its seventh audit in as many years.
"Overhauling DOD's financial management operations represent a challenge that goes far beyond financial accounting to the very fiber of (its) . . . business operations and culture," GAO chief David Walker told lawmakers in March.
Though Defense has long been notorious for waste, recent government reports suggest the Pentagon's money management woes have reached astronomical proportions. A study by the Defense Department's inspector general found that the Pentagon couldn't properly account for more than a trillion dollars in monies spent. A GAO report found Defense inventory systems so lax that the U.S. Army lost track of 56 airplanes, 32 tanks, and 36 Javelin missile command launch-units.
And before the Iraq war, when military leaders were scrambling to find enough chemical and biological warfare suits to protect U.S. troops, the department was caught selling these suits as surplus on the Internet "for pennies on the dollar," a GAO official said.
Meanwhile, Bush’s surge may not have the initial impact planned:
U.S. Marine Gen. Peter Pace admitted to the Senate Armed Services Committee Tuesday equipment will be a problem when U.S. forces in Iraq are increased.
During testimony over the $481.4 billion fiscal 2008 defense budget, Pace said the military has about 41,000 armored vehicles in Iraq -- fewer than will be needed "to cover all of the troops that are deploying."
Pace said it will be July before enough equipment is in place.
"The commanders on the ground have talked with the chief of staff of the Army and the commandant of the Marine Corps and have agreed that they will be able to share the assets on the ground so that no soldier or Marine will leave the compound without proper protection," Pace said when asked why more troops should be deployed immediately.
The question for Americans: had enough Republican incompetence?
_____________________________________________
UPDATED: FEBRUARY 3, 2007
WORLD VIEW
A BBC sponsored “world poll” conducted in 25 countries finds that America’s standing has plummeted – again. These critical facts emerge:
The number of those who said the US was a positive influence in the world fell in 18 nations polled in previous years.
In those countries, 29% of people said the US had a positive influence, down from 36% last year and 40% two years ago.
Across the 25 countries polled, 49% of respondents said the US played a mainly negative role in the world.
The poll tested seven policy questions related to Bush:
1. The war in Iraq: an average of 73% of respondents disapproved (57% in the US). Disapproval was strongest in Argentina and France, while people in Nigeria, Kenya and the Philippines were more likely to approve.
2. Detainees in Guantanamo: 67% disapproved (50% in the US). Backing for America on this issue was highest in Nigeria, where 49% approved.
3. Israeli-Hezbollah war: Washington's role met with approval from respondents in Nigeria and Philippines, but on average 65% disapproved across the 25 countries (50% in the US).
4. Iran's nuclear programme: again, support for US actions appeared strongest in Kenya (62%), Nigeria (53%) and the Philippines (52%). But, overall 60% of respondents disapproved (50% in the US).
5. Global warming: more than 80% of respondents in Argentina, France and Germany disapproved compared to 56% overall (54% in the US). But the White House had 50% or more support among those polled in Nigeria, Kenya, the Philippines and South Korea.
6. North Korea's nuclear programme: opposition to US policy was strongest among respondents in Argentina and Brazil. On average across the 25 countries 54% disapproved (43% in the US).
7. When asked about US military presence in the Middle East, an average of 68% of respondents across the 25 countries answered that it "provokes more conflict than it prevents".
Perhaps an equally important indicator of Bush’s standing in the international community is the action of international governments directly contradicting Bush’s policies.
Canada set an important example of decency when it offered a formal apology and compensation worth millions of dollars to a Syrian-born Canadian citizen who was a victim of President Bush’s use of open-ended detention, summary deportation and even torture in the name of fighting terrorism.
Last week’s announcement by Prime Minister Stephen Harper came more than four years after the nightmare began for the Canadian, Maher Arar, a 36-year-old software engineer. On his way back from a family vacation, he was detained by U.S. officials at Kennedy Airport on the basis of unsubstantiated information from the Canadian police. After being held in solitary confinement in a Brooklyn detention center and interrogated without proper access to legal counsel, he was sent to Syria, where he was imprisoned for nearly a year and tortured.
A court in Munich ordered the arrest of 13 people for the alleged abduction of Khaled el-Masri, a German citizen who says he was seized by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency and taken to a secret prison in Afghanistan.
Evidence collected by prosecutors yielded ``clearly identifiable'' individuals who may be undercover CIA agents, the Munich prosecutor, which obtained the warrants, said today on its Web site. The 13 could be charged with deprivation of liberty and aggravated assault for the alleged seizure of el-Masri on Dec. 31, 2003, in Macedonia.
El-Masri's claim of being kidnapped and flown to a prison where he was subjected to coercive interrogation has sparked a parliamentary probe in Germany and cast light on the U.S. practice of capturing terror suspects abroad and sending them to a third country, or ``extraordinary rendition.''
In Spain, a judge ruled on Thursday for the state’s intelligence agency to declassify any documents it has about secret CIA flights.
The actions of these governments are a clear reflection that the international community has lost tolerance of a President who violates international law. Simply stated, Bush’s conduct of foreign policy continues to isolate America within the international community.
NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE ESTIMATE
The latest National Intelligence Estimate for Iraq has been published. While most of the report is classified, the key findings can be read in its entirety at this hyperlink: National Intelligence Estimate.
These are some of the highlights:
[E]ven if violence is diminished, given the current winner-take-all attitude and sectarian animosities infecting the political scene, Iraqi leaders will be hard pressed to achieve sustained political reconciliation in the time frame of this Estimate [12 to 18 months].
Despite real improvements, the Iraqi Security Forces (ISF)—particularly the Iraqi police—will be hard pressed in the next 12-18 months to execute significantly increased security responsibilities, and particularly to operate independently against Shia militias with success. Sectarian divisions erode the dependability of many units, many are hampered by personnel and equipment shortfalls, and a number of Iraqi units have refused to serve outside of the areas where they were recruited.
Coalition capabilities, including force levels, resources, and operations, remain an essential stabilizing element in Iraq. If Coalition forces were withdrawn rapidly during the term of this Estimate, we judge that this almost certainly would lead to a significant increase in the scale and scope of sectarian conflict in Iraq, intensify Sunni resistance to the Iraqi Government, and have adverse consequences for national reconciliation.
Iraq’s neighbors influence, and are influenced by, events within Iraq, but the involvement of these outside actors is not likely to be a major driver of violence or the prospects for stability because of the self-sustaining character of Iraq’s internal sectarian dynamics. Nonetheless, Iranian lethal support for select groups of Iraqi Shia militants clearly intensifies the conflict in Iraq. Syria continues to provide safe haven for expatriate Iraqi Bathists and to take less than adequate measures to stop the flow of foreign jihadists into Iraq.
A number of identifiable internal security and political triggering events, including sustained mass sectarian killings, assassination of major religious and political leaders, and a complete Sunni defection from the government have the potential to convulse severely Iraq’s security environment. Should these events take place, they could spark an abrupt increase in communal and insurgent violence and shift Iraq’s trajectory from gradual decline to rapid deterioration with grave humanitarian, political, and security consequences.
In reading the NIE, one is stuck by the lack of any discussion of the potential increase in violence the mere presence of US forces generates. The NIE never mentions the fact that Shia and Sunnis agree that the US should leave Iraq:
Eight out of ten Shias in Baghdad (80%) say they want foreign forces to leave within a year (72% of Shias in the rest of the country), according to a poll conducted by World Public Opinion in September. None of the Shias polled in Baghdad want U.S.-led troops to be reduced only “as the security situation improves,” a sharp decline from January, when 57 percent of the Shias polled by WPO in the capital city preferred an open-ended U.S presence.
This brings Baghdad Shias in line with the rest of the country. Seven out of ten Iraqis overall—including both the Shia majority (74%) and the Sunni minority (91%)—say they want the United States to leave within a year.
Tom Lasseter catches the fatal flaw in Bush’s escalation:
The U.S. military drive to train and equip Iraq's security forces has unwittingly strengthened anti-American Shiite Muslim cleric Muqtada al-Sadr's Mahdi Army militia, which has been battling to take over much of the capital city as American forces are trying to secure it.
U.S. Army commanders and enlisted men who are patrolling east Baghdad, which is home to more than half the city's population and the front line of al-Sadr's campaign to drive rival Sunni Muslims from their homes and neighborhoods, said al-Sadr's militias had heavily infiltrated the Iraqi police and army units that they've trained and armed.
"Half of them are JAM. They'll wave at us during the day and shoot at us during the night," said 1st Lt. Dan Quinn, a platoon leader in the Army's 1st Infantry Division, using the initials of the militia's Arabic name, Jaish al Mahdi. "People (in America) think it's bad, but that we control the city. That's not the way it is. They control it, and they let us drive around. It's hostile territory."
The Bush administration's plan to secure Baghdad rests on a "surge" of some 17,000 more U.S. troops to the city, many of whom will operate from small bases throughout Baghdad. Those soldiers will work to improve Iraqi security units so that American forces can hand over control of the area and withdraw to the outskirts of the city.
The problem, many soldiers said, is that the approach has been tried before and resulted only in strengthening al-Sadr and his militia.
Bush’s invasion of Iraq triggered the civil war that is now devastating that nation. The civil war has turned into a trap. Bush will not depart because of the sectarian bloodshed that will follow when American troops withdraw and the United States cannot serve as a neutral force between the warring factions, perpetuating only continuing cycles of ethnic violence.
All of this lies directly on the shoulders of a President who manipulated intelligence and fabricated the justifications for the invasion.
THE FEDERAL DEFICIT
The Congressional Budget Office recently released its ten year analysis of the federal deficit. A thumbnail analysis of their findings can be summarized as follows:
The new CBO ten-year budget forecast shows improvement from last summer’s CBO forecast.
More than half of the improvement since last August, however, is due to arbitrary rules CBO must follow in projecting emergency supplemental appropriations; CBO says it reflects no “changes in the underlying budgetary environment."
The remaining portion of the improvement in the ten-year forecast is mainly due to lower projected Medicare and Medicaid costs, rather than higher revenues. The CBO data do not support claims that the tax cuts are paying for themselves and producing exceptional economic growth.
The CBO estimates also show that if current policies are continued (i.e., if the tax cuts and AMT relief are extended and no changes are made in programs such as Medicare and Social Security), combined deficits over the next decade will total $2.9-$3.4 trillion.
The CBO figures indicate that the long-term budget outlook remains grave.
The US Comptroller, David Walker, poignantly sums up how grave the picture is:
"The picture I will lay out for you today is not a pretty one and it’s getting worse with the passage of time," said David M. Walker, Comptroller General of the United States, in a Thursday morning hearing of the Senate's Budget Committee. "Continuing on our current fiscal path would gradually erode, if not suddenly damage, our economy, our standard of living, and ultimately even our domestic tranquility and our national security," he warned.
Walker heads the Government Accountability Office (GAO), the independent, nonpartisan watchdog of Congress that evaluates the spending of American tax dollars and advises Congress on improving government programs.
While he acknowledged the single-year fiscal improvement touted by the Bush administration for 2006, he said that "it did not fundamentally change our long-term fiscal outlook." He also noted that since 2000, America's net social insurance commitments and other fiscal obligations have increased to $50 trillion from $20 trillion, representing four times the nation's total economic output. Rising national health care costs are the greatest culprit according to data collected by Walker's agency.
The head of the GAO also warned that if no action is taken now to control government spending, severe tax hikes could be necessary. He stated that, "balancing the budget in 2040 could require actions as large as cutting total federal spending by 60 percent or raising federal taxes to 2 times today’s level."
Reuters, the only major news agency to offer coverage of Thursday's hearing, said that Walker saw the need for greater tax hikes in the interim, too. A Thursday evening dispatch reported, "Asked what level U.S. taxes revenues should be at, Walker said, "I can't tell you an exact number ... but more than 18.2 percent (of GDP), but below 25 percent.""
Bush’s escalation of the war in Iraq is not the only irresponsible policy that Republicans have hoisted upon the American public that will have long term consequences. The federal deficit will also haunt our children and our grandchildren.
Simple question for Americans: Had enough?
Last Update: 02/10/2007